Showing posts with label homeschool regulations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label homeschool regulations. Show all posts

The Importance of Independent Homeschooling

Many non-homeschoolers ask why homeschoolers who are doing a good job are opposed to stricter regulations regarding homeschooling. Here are some of the reasons.

  • Homeschoolers have seen time and again how petty Department of Education Bureaucrats and Public School Officials have misused and abused existing homeschool laws to harass homeschoolers.

  • Independent Homeschooling allows parents the ability to be flexible and adopt a curriculum that is suited to their child. The freedom to use the education method and the curriculum that works best for each individual child is what has made homeschooling the success that it is. We have no reason to believe that bureaucrats wouldn't try to impose the current educational fads on us if allowed to. See Why Homeschool: This sounds like a classic reason why public schools are having trouble.

  • By being freed of the constraints to keep the public school calendar homeschoolers are free to travel with their families, homeschool at the times best suited for their family, and adjust to accidents, family emergencies and illness.

There are many more reasons and I encourage my homeschool readers to leave a comment or a link telling their reasons. But as we are on summer break and today promises to be a beautiful day I am headed outside to work in the Whiskers Memorial Butterfly Garden.

Links to other post.

Consent Of The Governed: A CT Homeschool Icon Defends CT Families

Two Districts Demand Records

Warning for Virginia Homeschoolers

We don't need regulations

Additionally, national studies have shown that a high percentage of home-educated students go on to obtain advanced degrees. Area homeschoolers often meet for field trips or just child-to-child interaction, and even have graduation ceremonies. It’s school without the bells and lockers — and for many people, it’s a better way for their children to learn.

Including homeschoolers from Mississippi. Shining Celebi will be transferring to USA to earn his BS in Computer Science. At 18 he already has a degree from Mississippi Gulf Coast Community College.

The state of Mississippi is getting on board. Gov. Haley Barbour recently proclaimed this week to be Mississippi Home Education Week in an effort to bring some much-needed attention and understanding to this often overlooked method of child instruction.“It shows that the state is looking at home education as an option — a good option,” Michelle said as her children, who range from first- to eighth-graders, worked. “I’ve heard so many people speak negatively about home education, so maybe this will help.”

Mississippi is one of the best states to homeschool in. You simply register your child as homeschooled with the school attendance officer for your school district.

But we have to be ever diligent that our homeschooling freedoms aren't taken away from us. There will always be people like Stephanie that want the government to tell them what to do and how to do it. Frankly I wonder why she is homeschooling since she likes government control so much.

It would be easy for me to say that since I did such a wonderful job with Shining Celibi (he started college at 16) that everyone should use the same curriculum and methods I did. That since he took an Applied Ethics course in ______ grade all children in Mississippi should be required to do so. The grade is blank for the simple reason we don't do grades. He left the public school system at the end of his 5th grade year and we did High School level Honors and AP courses when we started homeschooling. All with out the 'regulations' Stephanie wants to saddle us with. Yes, it would be easy for me to set myself up as the homeschooling guru, so why don't I?

Because all kids aren't Shining Celebi. Our children are unique individuals. Homeschooling allows us to choose the best method for our individual child without government interference. It allows us to concentrate on the things we feel are important for our child to know without worrying about the latest educational fad. And it allows our children to achieve all that they can be.

HT Natalie One of T.H.E.M in NE MS

Deep Thoughts

Deep Thought asked thought provoking questions in his post Who Decides? Part II

In my introduction to education and homeschooling I discussed my conversation with Prof. Rob Reich, who is seen as an opponent by most homeschoolers, and his view that parents should not have sole control of the education of their children. His opinion was echoed in comments by Elliot, who feels that the government should determine what is taught to all children. These two people, along with many others outside homeschooling who discuss how to ‘limit’ it, or structure it, or regulate it, etc. all seem to touch on the core topic involved without quite realizing what that core topic really is. Even Prof. Reich, with a Ph.D. in Political Science, at first didn’t realize that regulation of homeschooling is about the power of the state to control or eliminate pluralism.

Of course one of the big problems is they don't see homeschoolers as diverse. According to the majority of non-homeschoolers, all homeschoolers are Christian Fundamentalist nut cases who raise their children in isolation. If you try to point out how diverse homeschoolers really are you get a grudging "maybe you are different" but............ If you dig deep enough into their hostility against homeschoolers you see they resent what they perceive to be all homeschoolers beliefs and they don't want them passed on to the next generation, as they perceive Fundamentalist Christian beliefs to be a threat to their own beliefs. They don't seem to understand that their own intolerance of beliefs differing from their own is a bigger threat then any Christian Fundamentalist or homeschooler could ever be.


How about today, when public school curricula actively promote stances that conflict directly with Catholic beliefs? If parents concerned with these issues can send their kids to Catholic schools, why not homeschool them? The Amish won a long court battle that allows them to have their own schools so that their children can be taught as their parents wish – including not following the compulsory education laws. Why are the legitimate desires of the Amish to pass on their beliefs and culture worthy of being honored, but not homeschooling parents who happen to be, say, pagans?
An excellent question.

In many ways, the desire to determine what homeschoolers can and cannot, must and must not, teach their children is just a shade of the Know Nothings and the Indian Office. It is someone determining that they know best, or at least better. It is the belief that someone, either yourself or an ‘expert’, is better/smarter/better educated/more ‘mainstream’ than a parent and that you need to intervene in how they raise their child – for the good of the children, of course! Eventually, with enough education, you can finally get the population all thinking the right things, believing the right truths, and acting in the proper manner….


I get so sick of all the anti-homeschoolers who claimed to want what is best for my children and subtly imply that I don't. They don't even know my children, so how can they presume to know what’s best for them. They certainly don't love them like I do, so why would I entrust my children's future to strangers? Then there are those who will admit that I am doing an excellent job homeschooling, that my children are thriving but still maintain that I should give it up for the "greater good", and call me selfish because I am not willing to sacrifice my children's future for someone else's child.


The issues, the hot buttons, all the things that get opponents of homeschooling frothed boil down to cultural outlook. This is why many on both sides focus on evolution/creationism. Those homeschoolers who leave public schools because of evolution clearly state that they feel the public schools are being used to subvert the beliefs and values that parents want their children to develop and support. While many who want to force all children to learn evolution claim that understanding evolution is a pre-requisite for being a functional adult.


The fact this is an argument against homeschooling is laughable if you hail from Mississippi in light of HB 625 - Introduced by Representative Mike Lott, the bill would require the teaching of creationism or intelligent design in SCIENCE classrooms if evolution is taught. One of the reasons I homeschool is so I can teach my children "pure science" especially the theory of evolution without having crackpot ideas like intelligent design introduced. Although I am rather fond of the flying spaghetti monster. But does it hurt me if another homeschooling parent chooses not to teach evolution? Of course not, and they should be free to do so.

Deep Thoughts left me with many interesting points to ponder. I hope you will go read his post in its entirety.

From The Blog World

Mother Crone is looking for a new approach to American History. I posted on this very issue at Home~Schoolers Rule in my post In Search of Amerincan History , American History Resource ~Leading Facts of American History and Let's Teach History Not Fairy Tales

HEM has a chilling post about mental health screening.

Heads up with our homeschooled families’ perfectly unique and mentally healthy brains intact, even with the push for ‘experts’ to poke around to determine whether they approve or not. I’ve been following the increasing states-wide and federal convergence of social/emotional goals with the use of questionable surveys such as TeenScreen. In Indiana, without parental consent or knowledge, the results of the survey ended with 2 diagnoses of a 15 year old girl (and a federal lawsuit) that should get your attention. Missouri has legislation introduced by Senator Days to have children “ready to learn”. “Ready for school” takes on a new meaning when it revolves around newborns on up.

HE&OS offers this Straw Men post on the same issue.

HEM posted on the homeschool issue in France, in French Legislators, E-Alerts and the Twelve Tribes.

PBS Profiles Homeschool Movement apparently buys into the myth that all homeschoolers homeschool for religious reasons.

And Life Without School ask What is your perspective?

From HE&OS

Daryl explains how Republicans are confusing homeschooling with part of the public education system.


Republicans are also committed to providing parents and students with the tools and choices they need to succeed. Charter schools, home schooling and online education are all choices that parents should have when they consider which environment will help their children meet with greater success. These options are particularly valuable to at-risk students, who in traditional public school settings often struggle to keep pace. All of these schools help to form our public education system, and deserve our support. We should always be looking for ways to help them advance and improve, while still demanding the accountability that our taxpayers deserve.

At the Cafe

Natalie post about how fellow blogger Valerie has a round up of letters supporting homeschooling in Mississippi sent to the Clarion Ledger, after they recently published media biased homeschooling articles.

Feel Good Policies

At Just Enough and Nothing More Tammy in her post Freedom vs. Controlled Dissonance? wonders why Hank Bounds is "out to get" Mississippi homeschoolers.
Homeschooling legislation to catch non-educating families is a feel-good idea. It makes people who are worried about “those parents” feel like they have some modicum of control. But as always, making legislation that effects how thousands of people live their lives in order to catch those select few who don’t want to be caught, is just bad law-making. It’s bad policy. Another important thing to is the role of the state. In this article, the superintendent says that it’s their role to “make sure that every child is receiving a proper education.”That is a misleading statement. If that were true, they’d be getting sued left and right. The state is not making sure every child is receiving a proper education. The state’s responsibility is to make sure that they OFFER every child and every family a place that they can receive an education.

Study: State ranks lowest in education

Mississippi ranked last in K-12 achievement and below average in fourth-grade math and reading, eighth-grade math and reading and the public school graduation rate.


That's right last, so maybe Mr. Bounds should spend more time worrying about how to improve the public schools and less time thinking up ways to harass (uh I meant regulate) homeschoolers.
Attempts to reach Bounds for comment were unsuccessful, but, in a Jan. 3 column, Bounds said the report "concludes that student achievement is influenced by a number of factors beyond the classroom, including pre-school opportunities, parental educational attainment and employment, family income and the median income of the community."

One can only wonder WHY Bounds wasn't anxious to speak with reporters about the low ranking of Mississippi's public schools. He certainly made the time to speak with the Clarion Ledger about homeschooling (which shouldn't be his concern, he is in charge of those low preforming public schools, not high achieving homeschoolers).
While Ocean Springs Superintendent Robert Hirsch said money should not be used as an excuse to not educate students, he said the results are the "simplest thing in the world to understand." "If the demographics of the state don't change, we may never see the change we're hoping for," Hirsch said. The problem, he said, is that the state is competing against other states that have higher average annual incomes and spend more money per student. Students in other states that allocate more money per student may have more opportunities.
It's not the money STUPID, homeschoolers spend less money per pupil then public schools do, but homeschoolers ofter rank higher in achievement.

From The Homeschool Cafe


Check out Natalie's post The Imperative of Lecturing (with actual content - blogger was giving us a headache), Update on "Quisling" homeschool panel, and Freep Freep ( a poll on No Child Left Behind).

Homeschool regulation: The revenge of the failures

Visit WorldNetDaily to read Homeschool regulation: The revenge of the failures by Bruce N. Shortt, Ph.D.



By attacking homeschool parents, Bounds is playing a familiar game. The goal is to distract the public's attention from the abject failure of the public schools for which he is responsible. After all, no government school system so thoroughly fails to educate as Bounds' schools. Nevertheless, Bounds wants the public to believe that the same bureaucrats who daily busy themselves producing massive illiteracy in Mississippi's public schools should have more power over homeschool parents, even though homeschooling parents are already doing a magnificent job with their children.
The oldest trick in the book, if you are incapable of doing your job properly try to shift the attention to someone or something else. My kids mastered this when they were toddlers, when told to clean up their room they would try to shift the attention to their brother's room. You would think Bounds would be too mature for such shenanigans.



Perhaps we can all agree with Superintendent Bounds in one respect, however. Mississippi does need more regulation of education. Consequently, as a public service, here is my modest proposal for reforming Mississippi's public schools: Homeschooling parents should regulate Bounds until the students in the government schools for which he is responsible academically outperform homeschooled children. Unfortunately, this recommendation is not likely to be accepted, which means that state superintendents of education around the country will continue to be able to tell parents upset about the job their local schools are doing, "Well, at least we're not Mississippi."
It's too bad Mississippi isn't willing to be innovative and allow homeschoolers to regulate the public schools, we could probably whip Bounds and the public schools into shape in a New York minute (OK, it might take a little longer).





For further reading visit the where you can read Natalie's post Re-Bounding Rebuttal.

Home Eating a Threat to Public Kitchens?

Since I love satire I couldn't resist this piece at Homeschool Christian.Com.

Home Eating a Threat to Public Kitchens? State Allows Growing Trend of Eating At Home by Angela Paul
After much heated debate on the house floor, legislation was passed today to allow a growing number of families to cook meals for their families in their homes. The children must have annual physical examinations to assure proper growth and weight gain. Attempts to require weekly meal plans and monthly kitchen inspections were voted down.

Click here to read the full post.

At The Homeschool Cafe


From The Cafe - Bounds Meets With MHEA


Natalie posted how Hank Bounds meeting with MHEA didn't reassure her, it doesn't reassure me either.

From the Cafe

It's so nice to have Natalie back, I was getting very lonely at the Cafe. You can drop by the Homeschool Cafe to read her new post The CL (Clarion Ledger for those of you not from MS) on Homeschooling, Anti Homeschooling Media Bias, and Shakespeare & Science (which happens to be my favourite; don't you just love it when homeschoolers succeed?).